Sinclair Seems To Have Cracked The FCC's Triopoly Code

Back in March, we questioned whether the FCC's approval of an Indianapolis triopoly was an isolated exception or an emerging de facto ownership rule. Eight months later, Sinclair seems to have its answer.

On November 13th, the FCC approved Sinclair's proposed acquisition of KRNV-DT (ROAR) in Reno, authorizing a triopoly alongside KRXI (Fox/NBC) and KNSN (independent/MyNetworkTV). That followed similar approvals for WSWB (CW) in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton in April and WBSF (CW) in Flint/Saginaw earlier this month.

Three markets, three triopolies, one regulatory playbook. Sinclair appears to have cracked the FCC's current ownership code—with more potential acquisitions already in its sights.

The Art Of The Third Station

The FCC's Local Television Ownership Rule still generally limits broadcasters to two full-power stations per market. Last year's Eighth Circuit decision eliminated the prohibition against owning two top-four stations, but a third still requires a waiver.

Sinclair's successful pitch is straightforward: Amid declining advertising revenues and digital competition, common ownership delivers efficiencies that support more local programming.

In Reno, Sinclair argued that existing joint sales and shared services agreements constrained its operations, while outright ownership would enable more news, sports, and community programming. The FCC agreed, citing KRNV's negligible audience share, uncertain standalone prospects, and remaining competitors.

The economics of combining facilities, personnel, and administrative functions are credible. Yet Sinclair was already operating alongside these stations. The waivers largely convert established relationships into direct ownership, removing contractual restrictions and consolidating control.

Here's the catch: Waivers are supposed to reflect special circumstances. Declining advertising revenues and digital competition, however, affect virtually every broadcaster. If those conditions justify a third station, what remains exceptional about the exception?

A Funny Kind Of Localism

The Reno approval has another revealing wrinkle: KRNV's primary affiliation is ROAR, Sinclair's wholly owned national comedy diginet. Alongside Comet, CHARGE!, and The Nest, ROAR distributes syndicated entertainment across local stations, aggregating audiences and advertising nationally.

So how does acquiring another license carrying Sinclair's own national programming meaningfully advance localism?

KRNV already shares operations with Sinclair's other Reno stations. Direct ownership strengthens Sinclair's control over a local broadcast license without inherently adding locally originated programming, independent journalism, or community accountability.

Sinclair promises expanded local service, yet the FCC's approval imposes no measurable requirements for additional local reporting, staffing, or programming. The efficiencies are tangible; the incremental public benefits remain unproven.

An Already Robust Pipeline

Sinclair's latest SEC filing reads like a prospective triopoly shopping list, detailing purchase agreements involving Cunningham Broadcasting stations in Baltimore, Columbus, Dayton, Charleston, West Virginia, and Greenville/Spartanburg, plus an option in Birmingham.

In Baltimore, Sinclair already owns WBFF (Fox) and WUTB (ROAR), while operating Cunningham's WNUV (CW). Columbus offers another potential triopoly involving WTTE (ROAR), alongside Sinclair's WSYX (ABC/Fox) and WWHO (CW).

The relationships extend beyond operating agreements. Sinclair consolidates certain Cunningham entities financially, while nonvoting shares of Cunningham stations are held in trusts benefiting children of Sinclair's controlling shareholders. These aren't announced acquisitions, but much of the operational and financial integration is already in place.

The pipeline is moving, too. Sinclair has recently sought to acquire WNAB (ROAR) in Nashville and KMYS (ROAR) in San Antonio, where it already owns two stations in each market. Both previously carried The CW before those affiliations shifted to subchannels of other Sinclair-operated stations. Radio+Television Business Report reports even more filings are in process to convert shared-services arrangements into direct ownership.

Sinclair CEO Chris Ripley underscored the momentum during the company's November 4th earnings call, citing three in-market station-group acquisitions over the past year and "many more in our pipeline across multiple counterparties within the industry." He described the regulatory environment as exceptionally favorable.

Sinclair's playbook is clear: Convert existing operating relationships into outright ownership, often of stations carrying its own national programming. The benefits to Sinclair are obvious. The added value to local viewers, much less so.

When Exceptions Become Policy

Other station groups are also taking advantage of the FCC's flexibility. Circle City's Indianapolis triopoly has been joined by Gray Media's approved combinations in Montgomery, Alabama, and Fort Wayne, Indiana, the latter subject to a future divestiture. Nexstar's TEGNA approval went further, permitting ownership of more than two stations in 23 markets, subject to divestitures, although antitrust litigation continues to restrict integration.

The mounting exceptions may soon become formal policy.

Last week, the FCC's repeal of the 39% national ownership cap was published in the Federal Register, with the repeal set to take effect January 11th of next year. The numerical limit will give way to case-by-case public-interest review. Though national and local ownership rules are distinct, both increasingly reflect the argument that greater scale helps broadcasters compete with digital media and support local programming.

As broadcast attorney David Oxenford recently observed, Sinclair's waivers follow much the same reasoning. With the FCC's Quadrennial Review still pending, broader local ownership changes could arrive before year-end.

The political calendar adds urgency. With Democrats taking control of Congress in January, the outgoing Republican-led Senate Commerce Committee hurriedly advanced Danielle Thumann Severs's FCC nomination on November 18th despite a Democratic boycott.

Congressional turnover won't change the FCC's Republican majority, but increased scrutiny and legal challenges could complicate further consolidation. Broadcasters have reason to accelerate acquisition filings and seek ownership waivers while regulators remain receptive.

Where's The Localism?

The fundamental question remains whether greater station concentration actually produces better local television.

Three stations sharing reporters, facilities, and editorial control may generate healthier margins and more newscast hours without adding meaningful original journalism. Acquiring another full-power license primarily carrying national entertainment programming makes an even thinner case for increased local service.

The skepticism isn't merely theoretical. Research by Stanford and other university scholars, examining earlier station acquisitions, found that coverage of local events and politics declined roughly 10% at Sinclair-acquired stations, although results varied among other groups.

Even the FCC's national ownership order acknowledges the distinct competitive risks of local concentration. Yet its recent local waivers rely heavily on promised efficiencies and programming expansions, with few measurable commitments or mechanisms for subsequent accountability.

In March, we questioned whether a single triopoly waiver might become a precedent. Sinclair has since turned that exception into a playbook, securing approval for additional licenses and greater operational control without corresponding guarantees of meaningful new local service.

For an agency charged with protecting the public interest, that's a remarkably one-sided bargain.

Local News To Peruse

Tim Hanlon

Tim Hanlon is the Founder & CEO of the Chicago-based Vertere Group, LLC – a boutique strategic consulting and advisory firm focused on helping today’s most forward-leaning media companies, brands, entrepreneurs, and investors benefit from rapidly changing technological advances in marketing, media and consumer communications.

Previous
Previous

Tube Trends: How Print Media Publishers Have Built YouTube Success

Next
Next

All Sports Are Local—Team Advertising Should Be, Too