How Local TV News Can Reconnect With Younger Audiences

In the latest episode of In the Vicinity, Tim Hanlon speaks with Magid COO Jaime Spencer and EVP Bill Hague about what the firm’s News Perception Index reveals about changing news consumption and how local broadcasters can respond.

Key takeaways include:

  • Context builds relevance: Audiences increasingly gravitate toward news brands that explain events and provide perspective.

  • Personalities build connections: Giving journalists room to develop authentic voices can help stations engage younger consumers.

  • Discovery happens across platforms: Reaching audiences under 40 requires a relevant presence on TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram.

  • Business models must evolve: Content, advertising sales, and audience measurement need to work across broadcast, streaming, and social.

Listen to the full In the Vicinity podcast above or get it on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.


Tim Hanlon: Hello there. You are In the Vicinity. Welcome. My name is Tim Hanlon, the founder and the CEO of the Vertere Group here in Chicago, where we consultatively advise bunches o' companies in the media and technology spaces. Some of them large, some of them small, some of them very much in between, and we are honored to have you in our presence this week as we take another look, a little walk down the road into the neighborhood here in the vicinity of local media.

That's what we kinda do around here. And we are honored to have two of the more senior folk from the consulting firm known as Magid, M-A-G-I-D if you're spelling at home, magid.com. If you've been in the television industry for any length of time, you will probably know the name Magid for decades of peerless research and consultative analysis around the television and local media landscapes.

They certainly do a whole lot more than just media these days, consumer brands and the like. You can find out more again at magid.com. But when it comes to things like local news and content in television Magid is perhaps the long-standing gold standard in helping clients divine what is around the corner in their world.

And the latest example of that just piqued my interest enough where I figured I had to reach out to Jaime Spencer, the COO at Magid, and my old pal Bill Hague, who's EVP there at Magid to talk about their newest concoction, or at least the newest revelation of such.

It is called the News Perception Index, and they talked about it a little bit at the NAB Show in New York just a few months back. But I wanted to dig in a little deeper as to what this thing was all about and all the various things that it is uncovering when it comes to consumers' news behaviors, and in particular local news.

And in part the local television news proposition, as we've talked about in many previous episodes, is very much compromised and challenged. The operations of such economies of scale that are the corporate owners of these TV stations are very much enmeshed in.

But I wanted to dig in a little deeper as to what Magid was finding in terms of how consumers were perceiving and receiving news and perhaps how that might inform their strategic consultative work with local news purveyors, the local newsrooms, the stations that own them, and perhaps what is around the corner for the proposition of linear TV news in local markets, and perhaps maybe a little understanding of what maybe it will take to stay relevant in the years ahead as news consumption evolves and changes.

All of that and more coming up now for you in our conversation with the folks at Magid, Bill Hague and Jaime Spencer. Here is the conversation we had just a few days back. Please, as always, enjoy.

Before we get into the nitty-gritty of all this, and thanks for making time, why don't you both briefly introduce yourselves and tell us a little bit about Magid for those who are uninitiated. I think most people who have been in the local television business in particular know the name very well and its legacy.

But obviously it's morphed and evolved over the years as the industry has changed and for those who are just completely uninitiated as to what you have historically brought intelligence-wise to the local media space. 

Jaime Spencer: Sure. Just quickly, I'm Jaime Spencer, chief operating officer at Magid.

And for those who may be uninitiated, Magid is a strategic advisory firm that's been in the business of making winners in the media landscape for 70 years. We've done that through training, coaching, consumer intelligence, strategy development, various different means. But we have worked in just about every aspect of the media landscape with a particular focus in news media and, historically, very much a focus in the local broadcast space.

Bill Hague: That was a great introduction. So I'm Bill Hague, EVP at Magid here in suburban Chicago, not far from where Tim Hanlon is seated. And I manage kind of corporate relationships, business development, partnerships within the firm, and have been here 21 years.

Jaime, you've been here at Magid…

Jaime Spencer: Almost 20. 

Tim Hanlon: That sounds lengthy and substantial. You obviously came to this from other worlds. Historically, the firm has been instrumental in helping develop things like the modern local newscast, the old action news approach, and personalities, and things like Q Scores and all that kind of stuff.

How did you two individually get to Magid, and what have you learned about the industry in that process from which I'm assuming were maybe more operational roles before you came into Magid? 

Jaime Spencer: Yeah I came to Magid after a stint in consumer public relations, and then I was actually a community journalist right before joining Magid on the print side.

I have taken a few hiatuses from Magid. I also served as a publisher for a Gannett daily paper for a time as well. But one of the things I'd say I've learned is that sort of alignment between the consumer and the strategy of any brand in the new space and how what one is looking at the other isn't always looking at.

One of the things I found fascinating as I came to Magid is this idea of, especially coming from public relations and thinking, after a week at Magid, I was like, PR firms are so off on how they're pitching stories with a desire to get them placed. There's just this massive disconnect, and it was really heartening to see and understand a firm like Magid sort of connecting those dots and bringing real consumer intelligence, real strategy to local media organizations so that they could serve the needs of their consumers.

I've always told people that media, news media in particular, is about as democratic a platform as you can consume. There's so much consumer data in the background that really these companies are just striving to deliver for the consumer what they want. 

Tim Hanlon: So you had real news and/or news adjacent experience.

Bill, did you come out of the news?

Bill Hague: So my first job in television was in the newsroom at Channel 4 in LA, KNBC. And then, out of college, I was at Warner Brothers, and then at CBS for a number of years on the television distribution side of things, where we lived and died by Nielsen and Arbitron ratings.

Back then we had two books every sweep. And what struck me, to your question, Tim, was the attitudinal research that we do. Attitudes precede behavior. We were looking at the wrong data. That told you what somebody did last night. What the work that Magid was doing at that time was all about. What someone's gonna do tomorrow. What they're gonna do next.

And that's what struck me when I joined the company, and literally, my brain hurt for the first couple of weeks with all the insights and the data and the methodologies and the strategy and the tactics and the activation based on those insights. 

Tim Hanlon: There's a huge irony here in that obviously, Magid historically has been very much involved in the sort of evolution of what you would call today's modern presentation of local news and the like.

And now as I try to deftly segue you've got something unique in the look forward department in and around news. This thing called a News Perception Index, which was ostensibly the reason why I wanted to reach out and see if you guys would wanna give us some background on that.

Because I think as we've danced around and certainly offline we've talked about this too, the importance of local news to television stations in particular, but to local media generally has never been more important and never more challenged. And this News Perception Index project or product possibly, was a huge antenna raise for me.

I'm curious if you could describe a little bit about what this is, this News Perception Index. What is it designed to do and we'll get into maybe some of the things that it's yielding for you so far in its early days. 

Jaime Spencer: Absolutely, Tim. And one of the things I would say is we wanted to take an approach that really embraced the omni media nature of the news landscape today.

We talk about Bill and I as we came into the firm and some of the things we'd seen at the time. But the reality is that this sort of platform delineated view of success still largely exists, especially in the local media landscape today, but not among consumers. Consumers have minutes of attention, and when they want to get news or they're exposed to news, they're investing minutes of attention on their phone or on TikTok or on a screen or streaming, whatever the case may be.

But they're making decisions around minutes of attention, and we wanted to build something that really measured the news landscape that way. So we've built this instrument that captures emotional attitudinal perceptions, perceived utilization of news brands. But more than 240 news brands that span everything from your 6:00 p.m. evening news at a national level, all the way down to creators and influencers who are covering news content at a much more micro level.

And when you do that, the results that show us how consumers are making decisions, what pulls them or how they gravitate to different brands, is very compelling and very telling. Bill and I talk a lot about the work we do and how we're working with clients.

And one of the reasons that we took this approach, and, I think it's already paying off in terms of what we're seeing in it, is this idea of getting that broader view and that understanding of how the consumer is making choices with everything they have in front of them, as opposed to how we think the consumer is deciding, whether it's two, five, or seven they're gonna watch at 6:00 p.m. tonight.

Obviously that sort of notion of consumer behavior is long, long gone. But how do we take those brands, those local brands, enterprise institutional brands that are still very strong from a trust and have a deep legacy in their communities, and help them evolve and move in the direction of the general consumer ideal?

That's really the point behind the News Perception Index. We field it a couple times a year. We're talking to about 5,000 consumers, so we can really break it down into a bunch of different ways. But that's the gist of it. 

Bill Hague: And what's really cool, if you think about, and Jaime mentioned it, the emotional attachment that consumers have, right?

So rather than just asking preference levels and is it up, is it down, right? We've taken a lot from our work in the consumer packaged goods and brand area to build this tool to really understand where’s loyalty, where's community, and how do you get to the literal heart and mind of the consumer and build that kind of trust and loyalty across multiple platforms.

Tim Hanlon: How much of this is locally flavored? Is there a bias, if you will, to local disseminators of news, or are you trying to be as broad as possible? Or how are you structuring that? 

Jaime Spencer: It is geography agnostic. It is purely at a brand level. Clients will oversample in their markets to get specific profiles of their brand relative to those other non-broadcast or non-local brands in their market.

But at a base level, it is purely at a brand level. 

Bill Hague: But what's interesting, Tim, to your question, because this term community comes up a lot and we ask a lot about it, most people think of that as a geographic concept or precept, right? When we ask about different news providers and individuals and networks and stations, you ask what has the strongest sense of community, in many ways it's national influencers.

And typically on one end or the other of the political spectrum. They created a sense of community much more than geographic news outlets, local news outlets. 

Tim Hanlon: So that's an interesting dynamic right there, is that the geography may or may not have any effect on this conception. What of your first couple of cycles of this stuff. What surprised you the most about how consumers have been perceiving or engaging with news today?

And I guess particularly, quote unquote, "younger audiences," and I suspect that you probably even have bands of ages within that subset. But I'm just curious to what is standing out to you and maybe surprising you a little maybe with and for your clients? 

Jaime Spencer: Yeah, there's a lot of things that are surprising and one of the things we love about this approach is we do a lot of research.

We look at the market in lots of different ways, and so it's hard to surprise us. We see all the things. But this does surprise us. And things that really put a maybe the exclamation point on thoughts or hypotheses in your head, one of the things we saw is this sort of from a brand standpoint, the end of the breaking news era and a gravitation towards a more context-driven brand.

People really do gravitate to the brands that give them more detail, context, perspective on the events of the day. Unfortunately, they also gravitate to brands that reaffirm their world views and perspectives more so than those that challenge them. But there's a lot to that, and just as an aside I would tell you that we see that shift happening more and more as you get to the younger end of the spectrum. I teach a business and media class at the University of Iowa, so I have 30 20- to 23-year-olds in that class, and we talk a lot about the news media, and I can tell you that not one of them can name one local anchor in the Cedar Rapids-Iowa City-Dubuque DMA, but all of them know who Aaron Parnas is, and all of them consume him.

And that's really the landscape shift we're seeing, is this momentum towards those more personality-driven, I almost hate to use that word because it's not like it's soft or fluffy, but just a more really authentic, not people who are trying to meet the criteria of authenticity, but are just really truly being authentic and sharing information that they're passionate about.

That's a big part of it. 

Tim Hanlon: In other words, they're not necessarily losing interest or have no interest in news, they're just their relationships aren't for lack of a better term, the traditional news organizations, right? Maybe individuals who came out of those organizations or have created their own as long as it's perceived as authentic and factual and that kind of stuff, it kind of belies a brand name or even a TV channel number.

No? 

Bill Hague: Here's what's really cool, just to riff on that and to focus on your earlier point about younger demos. We just had midterm elections last week as you are more than aware and most, and probably all of your listeners. We did a pre-midterm election study, and we did an election night study with a couple thousand people.

What was interesting in both, the people who were most engaged with that coverage was the younger end of the demo, 18 to 34. So this notion of we're never gonna get them, right? I was in a meeting with one of the large broadcast networks presenting this research, and I said, "You do not hear this from anyone. These 18 to 34s are super excited about your content." Those are words that are not said in those hallowed conference rooms in Manhattan and Los Angeles. So that's super interesting. The other thing that's interesting is the level of trust, both national and local, actually increased from that pre-midterm study to election night study.

So there's a little bit of a flow with trust across all demographics. There's some really encouraging signs for consumption. It's fractionalized, it's cut pretty thin in some places, but build it and they will come, as Steve Kornacki learned. 

Tim Hanlon: Yeah. Jaime, back to your point. You mentioned something in all of this called the indistinctiveness trap, where I guess if you translate this and these findings and these ahas into the current businesses of the local television station industry and the TV news brands and that kind of stuff it sounds like maybe there's the beginning or well into a misalignment.

Local TV news brands don't necessarily mean as much, if at all, to an increasingly growing audience base, where they can't maybe accord enough value to those brands or frankly don't find any distinctiveness between them, and maybe that's the wrong question in the first place. So I guess the question in there is: how are you translating some of these ahas into the language and the realities or the unrealities of the TV news business at the local level whose economics maybe don't necessarily align with this?

Jaime Spencer: It's a great question and a great point. The short version is safe brands are really not safe any longer. They're really this definition of mass and, even in heavy newscast consuming markets, you go into the top performing newscast of the day, and you get to, maybe crack into a double-digit percentage of an audience who's watching.

In many markets, bigger markets, you're talking about rounding up to a percent of the market. And I think that's almost permission to embrace this notion of the indistinctiveness trap. The younger you get, the more likely people are to engage with a person versus a brand. And that is a challenge, but it's also an opportunity.

There are great people at these institutional brands that do have a foundational level of trust, even amongst the youngest consumers. We need to lean into this notion of a whole generation that is used to consuming news-type media more like the three of us looking at each other in these screens here than in some big, huge, built up, puffed up presentation.

Leaning into your personalities, using them as conduits into the consumer base, into the community, really important aspect of this/ The other thing I would say is that if you are not in, what I call now the triangle of discovery, if you are not even just present but relevant on TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram, you're gonna have a really hard time building any brand affinity with people under 40 years old.

This is not like a teenager or a young 20s. Really, if you're under 40, you're gonna have a hard time connecting with that group without being relevant in those spaces. 

Tim Hanlon: So Bill, I will ask you then this follow-up to that. How do you then harmonize that with the economics of what's going on in the local broadcast television space where the first conversations seem to be probably around cutbacks and consolidation and operational efficiencies, yet Jaime's kind of almost espousing how do you transform into new touchpoints and that kind of stuff, arguably without the economics attached easily to those? Yeah. Shake vigorously.

How do you deftly convey these learnings into the realities of the business and gently or forcefully make the argument about how to transform maybe not just TV channels per se, but other things I think broadly?

Bill Hague: I think there's two transformations that need to happen.

There's the transformation across this omni-media landscape. So how do I play as a local TV station on all of these platforms and meet the consumer ideal on each, and then how also do I innovate at the same time on the sales side because the revenue is gonna come from advertisers. So how do I talk to those car dealers, personal injury attorneys, home services companies that make up the bulk of local advertisers, how do I talk to them and make sure they understand that I'm relevant on all of these platforms?

And there are consumers there, top of funnel to bottom of funnel, that will hopefully consume their product. That's the secret sauce. You can't just do it on the content side and build it and they will come, and hope on the sales side it will flow naturally. Because in the old broadcasting model where there were just a couple of channels that you'd flip around when you were a kid, we got thousands of choices.

Jaime Spencer: I would add a third on top of that for Bill, because I think those are completely appropriate. But the third leg of that same stool is the measurement system. The current measurement system that exists for particular broadcasters today is just gonna be a real impediment to succeeding in that omni-media landscape.

And I'm not even talking about, hey, how do we compare our Instagram exposure or our YouTube exposure? I'm talking about how do we count a view on linear versus streaming the exact same thing at the exact same time? That is a real challenge that these organizations need to face as well.

And as we go around the country talking to folks, it is one of the top-of-the-list items that they bring up. 

Tim Hanlon: Yeah, but you're almost describing kind of like a flywheel approach, which is massively innovative and seemingly logical the way we discuss it in this conversation. But it also seems enormously frightening to stations and groups that are economizing and consolidating, and maybe aren't necessarily strongly embracing of taking risk to reorient their newsrooms to be distributed in all these different places, some of which have no proven or intermediated distribution models where they're not in full control of the revenues.

Bill Hague: And that's where, Tim, the notion of painting or repairing the airplane while it's in the air is absolutely accurate. And how you do that luckily there's a lot of technology, innovations, AI, and other tools that are helping all of these folks do a lot more with the same or a lot more with less.

And we've got a collaborator publisher platform that is fed by our insights that a lot of our media clients are using for that reason and that purpose is how to flood the zone with more content but make sure it's still your content and brand safe. That we're really excited about.

And I think there's a lot of tools like that that get people to your promised land that you're describing. 

Tim Hanlon: Last question and then I'll let you guys unabashedly promote. The idea of local news has always been the heartbeat, if you will, of local television. It is the prime revenue generator, certainly around political advertising seasons but certainly it's also the purest form of ad revenue.

It's the most distinctive thing that it can offer in a market, and- It's the only thing they directly control versus syndication and/or network relationships and content that way. Given where you see this news perception index information coming your way and the way you describe it to them, how are you advising these entities now, knowing that this is the crown jewel of their enterprise, and it's being shaken and rewritten at its core? I can't imagine those conversations being easy. And maybe not without a hefty drink or two along the way or do you find your client base is grasping desperately for this kind of information from you guys to truly figure out how to reinvent themselves sooner rather than later? Have they gotten the joke yet? 

Jaime Spencer: I think there's definitely an awareness across the industry of what's happening. I don't believe local broadcast is naive. I think they're very clear-eyed about, at a high level, what's happening and where the trend is going.

And as we work with our clients we talk about several things. We work on several things from what is that brand definition? What is your brand mission, your brand in a way that can engage folks in a more omni-media type consumption environment that can remain relevant for those younger consumers who are building personal relationships?

How do you most effectively tie your talent into that, but also allow them to start not literally, but freelancing on different platforms, developing more of their own identity and making connection points that way. So that's a big part of it. That workflow operational effectiveness, it obviously takes people, it takes work to version content, to deliver content across platforms and the capital horizon of a publicly held company is not exactly a friend to that type of innovation.

It is a push and pull. You have to win at the margins. You have to find a tiny bit of capacity here and move it over there. And so when our teams are working to identify that capacity to reorient that workflow to something that is more in line with what the consumer wants today, it takes a lot of really on the ground.

Anybody can look at a bunch of spreadsheets and go, "Oh the norm of the industry is you should have two of these, and you have three, so you can just cut one." It's another thing to go sit in newsrooms 24 hours a day for multiple days to watch the handoffs, watch how people utilize their technology or don't.

How they're making those decisions, how long it takes to make those decisions. There's immense value in that observational work, and you put on top of that a consulting team that have all sat in those trenches, have done those leadership jobs. They're not Bain or McKinsey consultants.

We deliver a ton of value, and we do find those minutes and those hours at the margins to reorient these organizations toward more wholesale innovation and growth. 

Tim Hanlon: Yeah, Bill, I gotta also think too that there's plenty of younger folks working in these newsrooms that bring their own Gen Z or whatever sensibilities in terms of how they consume media and probably are almost chomping at the bit to do this. Yeah. Having the license of the brand to go into these different nooks and crannies, and maybe even showing the veterans maybe how this could actually truly work. 

Bill Hague: They've grown up with a pretty decent camera in their pocket, right?

A video camera in their pocket. So yeah, I think it's interesting. I think there's a lot of young folks who do bring that fresh sensibility of a creator or an influencer to a local TV station that the older, more legacy folks don't have. But I also think there's younger folks who wanna drive their father's Oldsmobile. It's interesting.

We find in a lot of newsrooms there's some young folks who just wanna be on that local 10:00 newscast and not do all the other things that Jaime's described and all these other platforms which is always surprising.

Jaime Spencer: It's interesting. You will see on social many of these young folks who work in these newsrooms, and I saw a couple clips the other day of a young meteorologist. And she does these clips on social that are reading comments from her social in her news voice. So she's almost embracing this notion in social that in her day job where she's doing hours a day of weather, she is faking it.

She's putting on this facade. And to Bill's point about feeling the desire to drive your father's Oldsmobile, they're almost intentionally doing things that they would not want to consume, which is inauthentic by definition. And that is a real challenge. I think they are chomping at the bit.

I think that the cultures of many of these organizations need to embrace that a little bit, even though there will be stubbed toes. Not all of it will be good. There will be lots of failures, but taking those shackles off and casting a news voice off into the ether is something that will need to happen for a continued presence, transformation, relevance and getting back to growth.

Tim Hanlon: I'd love to have you guys back in, I don't know, six months or so, and let's see how much this has evolved, how these learnings have maybe permeated the newsrooms and whatnot, and see if there's any evolution. And I would imagine, too, given the first half of next year in 2027 that's when the tide has rolled back from all the political advertising and stuff and lays bare the shoreline, if you will, of these local TV stations and their news operations.

And, it maybe puts a little bit more pressure or stress to make these evolutionary changes more quickly than perhaps this year might have allowed. 

Bill Hague: That's exactly it. And that's what's exciting, right? It's moments like that when the greatest change happens.

And we're changing what we do based on the consumer, based on the audience, based on the needs of the marketplace as much as our clients are. I'm very encouraged. It's not gonna be easy, but I am very encouraged.

Tim Hanlon: All righty. My thanks to Messrs. Hague and Spencer for that illuminating conversation. And boy, as the local news proposition could not be more challenged, and lots more to talk about. Hopefully in the months ahead we'll try to have Bill and Jaime back on to talk about where things have evolved in local news, and perhaps some of the other projects that are going on in the Magid world.

You wanna find out more about the firm, you can go to their website, Magid, M-A-G as in George, I-D, magid.com. And again, Bill and Jaime are two of the leads there in and around the methodologies and consultative work in the media space that Magid occupies. They do a lot of other stuff too, consumer brands and other verticals as well.

But you can check out all of that stuff there at the website magid.com. And look forward to having them back again sooner rather than later. Our thanks of course to our friends at TVREV who put up with us each and every week and provide us the resources for getting this out to you. We appreciate you listening, of course.

That's our friends Melissa Hourigan and Jessika Walsten and Mike Gasbara, and the almighty Jason Damata, the chief cook and bottle washer there. Thank you everybody there at tvrev.com for allowing us to do this for you once again. And of course, Jerry Payne for his audio excellence, without whose work we could not get this out to you each and every week.

And thank you for listening. And please tell your friends and have them tell two friends, and so on. We appreciate it, and we'll see you hopefully here next week In the Vicinity. Take care.

TVREV

TVREV captures the voices and insights of executives in the TV, digital and advertising industries. Our insights, reports, newsletters, videos and events are guideposts for everyone in the greater television ecosystem, from programmers and distributors to advertisers and adtech companies.

Previous
Previous

Do Creators Really Sell More Than TV?

Next
Next

Magnite’s Matt McLeggon On Why Streaming Ad Dollars Still Haven’t Caught Up With Streaming Audiences